Joss Whedon’s Batgirl Escalates the DC Vs Marvel Battle

Ryan Aday
Movies Comics
Movies Comics DC Marvel

Joss Whedon will dip his toes back into the world of comic film with the new Batgirl movie. The announcement came down today that Whedon will write, produce, and direct the adventures of DC Comic‘s female caped-crusader. Considering the success of Whedon’s Avengers series and the lackluster performance of DC’s first couple of motion pictures, this makes sense. However, is this the first of many Marvel talents defecting to the DC universe?

What We Know

Here’s what we know. Joss Whedon expressed many times that he was worn out by the Avenger series. In an interview with Vulture about making the next Avengers movie he noted:

“They came to me about the movie and what I said was ‘I’m tapped out…and I think they knew that even if I could give them something, it wasn’t going to be anytime soon .”

Whedon spent half a decade with the Avengers series

We also know that a large obstacle to finishing Avengers: Age of Ultron lay in a constant creative battle with executives. Many times expressing his desire to go back to his own creative “universe”.

“I gotta say, it’s been dark. It’s been weird. It’s been horrible. About a month and a half ago, I said goodbye to my kids, and I’ve been living in Burbank next to the studio. I feel every day like, I didn’t do enough, I didn’t do enough, I didn’t do enough. I wasn’t ready. Here’s failure. Here’s failure. Here’s compromise. Here’s compromise.” (Buzzfeed)

“The last thing I did before The Avengers was [directing an episode of] Glee, and in between I did Much Ado About Nothing. So I haven’t created my own universe for over five years. That feels wrong.”

What This Means

Whedon is a main eventer who might help switch the tide in the cinematic universe war

Using this logic, signing on to a project of this magnitude counteracts those statements. To me, this indicates two major developments: 1) DC offered Joss Whedon a ton of money. 2) Whedon must have obtained a tremendous amount of creative control.

What This Resembles

This new slant in the battle of the iconic comic book companies is similar to the beginning of wrestling’s Monday Night Wars. In the same way that Marvel’s superhero line-up currently dominates the comic book movie landscape, the juggernaut World Wrestling Federation (WWF, now known as WWE) once reigned as the undisputed king of wrestling. World Championship Wrestling (WCW) wanted to compete with the top dog and aimed to surpass their success.

Big paydays and creative control were two big topics in another high profile media battle

To begin with, WCW missed the mark, similar to the way DC failed with poor response to Batman v Superman and Suicide Squad. With WCW unable to measure up to the lofty standards of WWF, they decided to hire their competitors’ top talent. In their negotiations with these stars, WCW adopted two strategies in an effort to compete. First, they offered more money with guaranteed contracts. Second, they allowed for the talent to have creative control of their characters.

Taking WWF’s top talent escalated the war between the two companies and the Monday Night Wars were born. Over the next three years, the two companies battled for ratings supremacy. WCW prevailed for almost a year and a half, proving the strategy effective. More importantly, it drove the two companies to step up their game, rewarding fans of both brands.

Now that DC have managed to woo Joss Whedon over to their side, is this the direction we are headed in the Comic Universe battle? Could the DC movie universe be hunting for writers, producers, directors, or even actors from the Marvel Cinematic Universe? Will we start seeing more of Marvel’s top talents defecting to DC with the promise of more money and creative control? If DC are copying this strategy, then hiring Joss Whedon is a massive win as they prepare for war.

Ryan Aday
Ryan is a former college athlete with a degree in Communication from Point Loma University. He is also a 5-time Game Show Contestant (Incl. Wheel of Fortune) and decorated fantasy football player (Fantasy Football Evolution National Champion Runner-Up). Mr. Aday is kind to animals.
Become a
Pop culture fans! Write what you love and have your work seen by millions.