It Happened on Halloween: The Best Horror Movies Set on October 31

Danielle Ryan
Horror Movies
Horror Movies

There are plenty of amazing horror films out there, but for Halloween, we wanted to pick something special. To celebrate the spookiest day of the year, we picked our favorite horror movies that actually take place on October 31. Trick or treat!

Halloween III: Season of the Witch

Halloween will always be the film that defines this holiday, and its masterpiece status is more than deserved. However, despite its title, the story doesn’t actually have much to do with the holiday. It’s the series’ third installment that really embraces All Hallows’ Eve and utilizes it to its fullest potential.

The story involves a maniacal corporation who happens to be the nation’s largest and most popular provider of Halloween masks who plan to return Halloween to its more sinister roots. Through repeated commercials, the company instructs children to buy these masks and wear them at a precise moment while watching TV. Thanks to some technological wizardry that involves small fragments from Stonehenge (yup), anyone wearing the masks while watching a particular program will have their heads turn into bugs and snakes.

Needless to say, Halloween III: Season of the Witch is bonkers. I didn’t even mention the evil androids, did I? Yeah, the movie has those as well. Halloween is a necessary watch for this time of year, but real fans know that Halloween III is where you go to get your yearly dose of insanity.

[Drew Diestch]

Night of the Demons

When the weird goth girl at school throws a party in the town’s haunted house, just about everyone in attendance dies and gets possessed. That’s the gist of Kevin Tenney’s late-’80s Halloween cult classic, Night of the Demons. The film has a massive underground following with hardcore horror fans and still holds up as one of the creepiest movies of its era.

Back in the glory days of VHS rental, Night of the Demons freaked out curious kids looking to find thrills and chills in the horror section. The key art for this movie depicted the iconic goth-turned-bride of the devil, Angela, post-demonic possession. It’s a striking image and one that stuck in my head for years.

Night of the Demons starts out simple enough: dumb kids go to a dumb house and do dumb things. The elements that make this one a Halloween classic are the performances, the horror SFX, and the tone. It’s all harmless gothic fun until the kids get bored and play with the occult, then all hell breaks loose. The movie is chock full of tropes, but no other haunted house movie is quite like it.

Night of the Demons is fun, frightening and a definite must-see for Halloween horror fans.

[Andrew Hawkins]

Trick ‘r Treat

Michael Doughtery highlights the mythic qualities of Halloween in Trick ‘r Treat. Although it’s an anthology film, the stories all intertwine and connect in some way. The stories range from hilarious to bone-chilling, but they all convey that adrenaline rush of being scared.

Trick ‘ r Treat’s real accomplishment is Sam. Dougherty created Sam — named after the original pagan name for Halloween, Samhain — because he felt Halloween needed a mascot. Christmas has Santa, Easter gets a bunny, so why doesn’t Halloween have its own figurehead? Sam embodies the sweet and scary aspects of the holiday perfectly. His raggedy costume is instantly iconic, and wait until you see what’s under that mask.

Trick ‘r Treat is definitely one of the new classics in the horror genre. It’s a gorgeously shot film that captures the glow of Halloween like no other movie. The film is littered with jack-o-lanterns and warm light and it just feels like Halloween. There is no other way to describe it.

[Drew Dietsch]

The Guest

After the success of their 2011 horror film, You’re Next, screenwriter Simon Barrett and director/editor Adam Wingard teamed up for The GuestThe Guest doesn’t have to take place around Halloween to be effective, but the final sequence involving a homemade haunted house in a school gymnasium is gold.

The Guest features Dan Stevens as David, a soldier who came back from Afghanistan and wants to visit the family of his fallen comrade. He also isn’t exactly who he says he is, though the family he infiltrates seems to like him well enough.

As teenaged Laura uncovers more about David’s past, things start getting scary. He’s one seriously unhinged dude, and he comes after Laura with a vengeance when she threatens to reveal the truth about him. Sharing too much more could spoil the movie, so let’s just say the film’s climax takes place in a haunted house. Complete with fake fog, black lights, and spooky surroundings, it’s the perfect setting for a particularly memorable chase sequence.

[Danielle Ryan]

Ginger Snaps

Much like The Guest, Ginger Snaps doesn’t really need to be a Halloween movie to work. But the October setting fits the film’s tone and structure so well that Ginger Snaps is now a cult Halloween gem. This bitingly funny werewolf movie is the brainchild of Orphan Black producers Karen Walton and John Fawcett.

Sisters Brigitte (Emily Perkins) and Ginger Fitzgerald (Katharine Isabelle) use their gothy angst as a way to get through the nightmare of high school. But as summer turns to fall, something awful happens — family dogs start dying, shredded by some unseen creature in the night. And when the beast snatches Ginger and mauls her, miraculously, she heals. But in the following weeks, she begins a slow transformation into a wolf-like monster.

Culminating on Halloween night, the story of the Fitzgerald sisters is a descent into bloody terror. And while you don’t need Halloween to make an effective horror movie, this film’s fall setting is thematically appropriate for a story about slow change.

[Travis Newton]

Creepshow

The first image we see when Creepshow starts is a jack-o-lantern. The film makes its intentions known right out the gate: it’s time to have some frightful fun. And boy, is Creepshow the definition of frightful fun. This celebration of EC Comics is a joyride through the horror genre. The five tales — plus the wraparound — spare no expense when it comes to dishing out some colorful spooks.

The stories run the gamut from zombies to alien organisms to killer cockroaches and more. All the horror bases are covered and always with a gleeful attitude. Director George A. Romero and screenwriter Stephen King act like kids in a blood-soaked candy store. Their obvious love of the old Tales from the Crypt comics shines through in every lurid second of the film.

Creepshow is grade-A Halloween fare that exemplifies everything exciting about the holiday. There are loads of laughs and technicolor terrors bursting from every seam of this patchwork nightmare. It’s a great flick to show people how much fun you can have being scared. And thanks to that opening shot of a jack-o-lantern, it makes the cut for this list.

[Drew Dietsch]

Danielle Ryan
A cinephile before she could walk, Danielle comes to Fandom by way of CNN, CHUD.com, and Paste Magazine. She loves controversial cinema (especially horror) and good cinematography; her dislikes include romantic comedies and people's knees.
Become a
FANDOM
Contributor
If you're an aspiring pop-culture writer, we want to hear your voice! Write about the topics you love and have your work read by millions.